Showing posts with label Xinjiang. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Xinjiang. Show all posts

Tuesday, June 28, 2016

Asian Calmination - Cambodia

Cambodia
I was excited to cross the border. Besides Hong Kong to Shenzhen, real land crossings have been missing from my life. The process didn't meet expectations though, with lots of waiting time in no man's land and no interesting bits, save the exchange of crisp US dollars. In Cambodia, the ride was very rural until suddenly crossing the Mekong River, urban Phnom Penh arose with little warning. My hostel, 19 Happy House Backpacker, was a couple blocks away from our dropoff point, at #59 Street 13. A wrong turn and a dozen blocks later, I was lost with the early afternoon sun really weighing down on me and my red backpack. When I finally reached the hostel, the staff could not find my booking. Minutes of awkward confusion later, I realized I was at Happy Backpacker, a separate establishment. I circled around even more confused, as Street 13 was somehow between Street 15 and Street 5. I came across #60 Street 13, which was some Malaysians' home. Malays speak English which is great, but they had never heard of Happy House Backpacker despite my protests that it must be next door. Some venting later, I kept walking down the street and finally saw the sign for 19 Happy House several blocks away. I learned the hard way that street numbers have absolutely no meaning in Cambodia.
Spark - eccentric establishment
My first night in Phnom Penh included pickup ultimate with the young athletic Swa players on a barebones mini turf pitch, followed by many beers at a concert hall/beer hall/replica Italian plaza/microbrewery/cafeteria called Spark (complete with sinks specifically designed for pukers in the bathroom) with Asian Ultimate legend Jared Cahners. I learned that the fellow Newton native has been living in and out of Asia since the 1990s, coming to Cambodia for his PhD but quitting shortly before we met, and had various histories of fluency in Mandarin, Vietnamese and Khmer. In between, I met a Japanese/Chinese/Thai Wellesley College graduate Clinton Global Health employee looking for someone to analyze malaria data, a Peace Corps volunteer and some of the pioneers in Cambodian ultimate. I always enjoy entering a new city and observing the makeup of the economy, and the makeup of the foreign population.  Throughout Asia, English teachers abound, but in Cambodia I met many aid workers/NGO veterans. This influx gives Phnom Penh a distinctly non-traditionally Asian feel. The downtown is awash in bars and pizza/Chinese food joints with stories traded in English and French.

I didn't have the best time in Cambodia. Everywhere I felt like locals were constantly trying to fleece the last buck out of me, and it really wore me down. Sure, this vibe was prevalent in all the former communist countries I visited (Vietnam and Laos) but most evident in Cambodia.  Ironically, while I attribute communism for the uninspiring aspects of Cambodia, a better understanding of the rise of communism is my best takeaway from the country. While Phnom Penh dates back to the 15th century, and was called the Pearl of Asia in the 1920s, it doesn't feel like an old city. The French and the Communists had left a grid of dusty and sweaty streets, old architecture too rundown to exude any colonial charm and a skyline dotted by a handful of uninspired modern high rises. There are some golden Wats scattered throughout the city and a major boulevard with a pretty monument in the center, but it struggles to compare to the temples of neighboring Thailand. And though I did not find Khmer cuisine bad per se, my palate was so well primed before and after in Vietnam and Thailand.

The ugly legacies of communist rule, and specifically the bloody genocidal Khmer Rouge regime, are thus still very tangible. The government was brutally anti-intellectual, killing most anyone with glasses, education or foreign language knowledge. The country's genocide caused the deaths of around a quarter of the population, an astounding culling of 8 million down to 6 million. When you lose an entire generation of cooks, architects, bureaucrats and writers, cultural devastation is inevitable.

I never really understood communism in history classes. We studied so much about its deleterious effects that it never made sense how such extreme practices took hold in the first place. I read Lenin in high school and Marx in college and still had no idea. But my second day in Phnom Penh involved visiting the Killing Fields outside the city, where hundreds of skulls are prominently shown, and the S21 school-turned-prison-turned-museum, which documents accounts of the atrocities that occurred there. Walking through history, I learned that Pol Pot as a frustrated failed man, who despite an education in France, rode a populist ideology that villainized the educated elite, foreign influences and minorities. The Khmer Rouge promoted rural ethnic Khmers as the backbone of Cambodian society, preaching self-reliant isolationism. If any of that sounds familiar and scary, reread what the regime did after they got into power and be even more scared.

I had planned to be in Cambodia for a brief two stops, before reaching Bangkok for an ultimate tournament. However I mistook the tournament to be a week earlier than it was, giving me another week to explore Cambodia. I'm not much of a beach person, but I figured a southeast Asian trip was incomplete without one, and so I ventured south to the resort town Sihanoukville. There awaited miles of pristine beach facing the Gulf of Thailand, and a bizarre mixture of expensive restaurants and hotels, dirt-cheap bungalows and hammocks, and a bunch of nothing in between.  Young Europeans who were lazing around the hostels for weeks on end seemed to outnumber any other demographic. They were apparently not my group, for in a backpacking rarity, I actively tried to  go out hard and have a good time and came out with no memorable stories whatsoever. Maybe it didn't help that I spent the day reading research papers in my air-conditioned bungalow and was looking for people with whom to discuss global income equality. Sorry I'm just not a beach person.

I quickly moved on to Kampot, a river town that was much more my kind of place. Just two hours away, the demographics could not be more different, with a local economy grounded on its famous pepper rather than tourism. The city's key attraction was an enormous durian sculpted into the middle of a major traffic circle. A conversation the previous day with friend John Johnson alerted me to an abandoned town between Kampot and Sihanoukville, but it was tough to verify on Google. Exploring a charming collection of expat-friendly riverside bars on the east side of the river, I found some seasoned expats engaged in academic research. I asked them about this abandoned town, and the expats enlightened me about Bokor Hill Station. One of them showed me the Google streetview, and pointed at himself standing next to a church. "I was there when the Google Earth guy was walking around with all the cameras!" I resolved to go the next day. 

Curious about the opposite riverbank, I explored a bridge closed to traffic and found a hole in the barrier, evidently used by pedestrians. I snuck over to the west side and found a decidedly more local scene. At an outdoor club blaring Khmer music, I ordered iced beer and cow entrails. On the way home, I passed by the durian, took one sniff of its imaginary scent, and threw up the entrails.

The next morning I was back on a motorbike for the first time since my Sapa fall. From a purvey of Googlemaps, the trip seemed like a 40 minutes straightshot on one major road. However at the 40 minute mark I reached the ticketed entrance to the mountain road, and I realized that the Hill Station was of course, up on a hill, and that Google hadn't quite charted that winding Cambodian mountain road. I drove up into the unknown, made a sharp turn around a bend and nearly fell off my bike. The mountain sloped into the Gulf of Thailand to the south, and the ocean winds crashed down unimpeded. The winds affected me mostly on the hairpin turns, when I slowed down dramatically. More daring motorcyclists zoomed past me on those turns, but I wasn't shamed out of braking - my nerve had left with my palm skin in the mountain gravel of North Vietnam. Finally I reached the top of the mountain, past the construction of a monstrous modern casino, a budding tourism park, some sanitation pump stations. Hiking up a grassy clearing, I found a solitary stone church. A bench that could have been lifted right out of Paris sat undisturbed in front. The church's stonework was definitely weathered, but otherwise everything was in remarkably good shape.  The doorway arch was doorless and I walked into an eerie interior. The multi-scripted graffiti covering the walls and the flower pots in front of religious statues reflected a dichotomy between disdain and worship. A small Jesus on the crucifix still hung overlooking it all, silently witnessing decades of good deeds and sins.

There were no explanatory plaques, but the area had been settled by the French in the 1920s, providing a cool getaway from the stuffy Phnom Penh. It was abandoned by the French twice, ultimately to the Khmer Rouge, and was even used by their remaining forces after a Vietnamese invasion overthrew the regime into the 90's. Now Cambodia has been stable enough that the area is being developed, and the ghost town may itself ghost away. The lack of historical preservation is understandably not a focus (any cultural preservationist would be busy further north), but it still saddens me that so many stories there go untold. With no public information, I had very nearly missed this site.

I had already spent way longer on this hill escapade, and hurried back, driving past the large abandoned Bokor Palace Hotel that was apparently even cooler. The ride down the steep mountain slopes was interminable and I couldn't wait to never drive a motorcycle again. Returning to Kampot in the late afternoon, I was stunned to learn that there were no more bus options returning to Phnom Penh. Turns out the start of the Chinese New Year affects commerce in Cambodia as well, and buses simply stopped operating. The Super Bowl was the next day and definitely watchable in Phnom Penh. Wikitravel did list one alternate form of transportation - car pool. And so I found a bunch of drivers and agreed to pay $20 USD to join an unknown number of people for the 4 hour ride to the capital. I waited in the park for 2 hours, and finally there were 3 other Cambodians joining. The sedan driver and I made 5, and as we hit the main road, I thought to myself this wasn't so bad - Wikitravel had warned that these carpools often crammed 7 into the same car. As soon as I counted myself lucky, our car slowed down and I had to scoot in for another passenger. And then we stopped again, and two woman were sharing the shotgun seat. As the 7 of us drove down the road, imagine my surprise when we slowed again. I shuddered to think of 5 of us fitting in the back, but instead the driver got out and then essentially sat on the new passenger's left lap. And the 8 of us in this clown car of a sedan made our way up to Phnom Penh for the start of the year of the monkey.

Watching the Super Bowl in a Texas-themed bar in Phnom Penh was an experience, but the game sucked and I moved on to take a minibus to Siem Reap. Here again I was a victim of Cambodian capitalism. The minibus was run by a minor agency and not easy to find, and my desperation at potentially missing the ride was showing when I asked a tuktuk driver for help. He ended up taking me for a $1 ride, and literally drove around the block back to where we started and pointed out the agency. Upon landing in Siam Reap, I luckily had saved my hostel location on Googlemaps and realized it was a 3 block walk. I was harassed by tuktuk drivers anyway, and I gave one the address as a test. A $1 ride would have been generous, but this guy brazenly asked for $5. I was more than willing to contribute to the local economy, but such shameless disrespect honestly infuriated me. I told him to fuck off and walked.

No place on my path was as touristy as Siam Reap. In contrast to the well ordered geometry of the nearby ancient sites, the modern city felt like a disorganized cantina of businesses clumped every which way to mine that tourism gold. Hotels and restaurants catering to tourists of all types face each other with services advertised in English, French, German, Chinese and Korean.

Hostel owners advised me it was possible to rent a bicycle at 5am. Indeed it was, but I had to jump over the locked gate of the hostel first. Though I'm not much of a morning person, I biked the 8 miles out of town and reached Angkor Wat an hour before sunrise. The classic view of Angkor Wat at dawn is usually taken in front of a lake, but a tenth of humanity was camped out on that spot. I thought I could take an equally impressive shot from a different angle, and jostled with a separate large group of people for position. I failed to capture any decent photos from the front, except perhaps this one of the crowds. I raced through the temple and tried to process everything. The palace was immense yes, but each column was still intricately carved, the stonework carefully laid. Statues and murals were so commonplace that negative space was a rarity.
Angkor Wat from the back

Nowhere was I more negatively affected by hype than here. I had heard so much of these ruins and even the previous night, a hostel mate had talked about the spiritual experience of witnessing the sun rise in Angkor Wat. In front of the building, surrounded by thousands of people, I did enjoy the bright hues of the morning sun...but I was not spiritually moved. Perhaps my favorite part of the experience was reaching the back of the complex, the sky still in the later stages of dawn, and looking out into the relative peace of the jungle. Whether I like it or not, preconceptions heavily influence my enjoyment, and it is no surprise that some of my favorite experiences on this journey were ones that I had no expectations of at all.

The whole set of ancient temple complexes is often collectively referred to as Angkor Wat, but Angkor Wat is only the biggest of the temples in the Angkor ruins (Angkor means capital city, Wat means temple). Angkor is undoubtedly the largest and most famous of the many temple ruins attractions in Southeast Asia (of which this trip included 2 others), all with a Buddhism-appropriating-Hinduism shared history. Dating primarily from the 12th century, the city is believed to have been the largest pre-industrial city in the world, spanning 390 square miles, before essentially being abandoned and lost to the jungle for centuries. Angkor Wat is so impressive, reaching the height of a 20 story building, and so revered, being the only building in the world to be featured on a national flag.


I biked over 40 miles that under that brutal Cambodian sun, stopping for coconut water whenever possible. I saw a temple in a marsh, a temple with a giant tree growing through it, and the temple that Lara Croft/Angelina Jolie had run through. By the early afternoon, I was unable to appreciate the ancient wonders around me - I had had my temple run.

There were plenty of temples I didn't get to on my one day of biking, but I didn't go back out the second day. Sure I felt bad, drinking beer in a cafe in the vicinity of some of the worlds' greatest treasures, but I was so tired it was a no-brainer of a decision. Even worse I was cognizant that my lack of appreciation of the temples was a product of my western education. I've learned enough about gothic arches and flying buttresses to admire European cathedrals, but I don't know the first thing to look at when staring at the Hindu/Buddhist temples. I don't know the difference between a temple dedicated to Vishnu or Rama, and the murals tell stories that make no sense to me. Clearly the course of action is to study this history, but I prefer to blast the parochial scope of my education. I explored the rest of Siem Reap that day, and was surprised to find a functioning town with some non-tourist economy, and a very touristy street creatively called Pub Street. Wandering through town, I got hassled nearly every block by a tuktuk driver offering to take me to the temples. Unable to find a respite, I walked straight to the bus station and bought a ticket to Bangkok the next day.

Asian Calmination - Vietnam

The giant red backpack is completely deflated. At its peak it bundled 30 odd pounds and imprinted its shoulderstraps onto my body.  Long hauls in bus hulls and nights on dirty hostel floors has bruised the polyester casing. Somehow it held up and protected my laptop, my clothes and my sanity over the many miles.

The longest trip I've ever taken feels very epic to me and my little world. By plane, train, boat, bus, motorbike or carpool, I made my way through the unfamiliar. I had my resolve tested deep in the jungle, survived hairy motorbike experiences, crossed five land borders, crashed an aviation annual gala, squished into a clown car, bathed an elephant, soared over the rainforest, drunkenly floated down a river, climbed a waterfall, prayed in an abandoned church and refreshed my trove of good stories. I ran into a college teammate in Bangkok, explored the best coffee shops in Luang Prabang and was offered jobs in Phnom Penh and Chiang Mai. I ate street food everywhere but miraculously never got food poisoning, or even had a calamitous toilet encounter.

I had been thinking about a trip like this for a while. I'd enjoyed traveling before I moved to Hong Kong, but 4 years in a great jumping off point fed a growing travel appetite. The more of the world I saw, the more of the world I realized remained to be seen.  Many cities were accessible by short flights, but plenty of fantastic less urbanized areas were beyond the reach of the weekend warrior. If I were to leave Asia, I had always planned on allowing for a lengthier trip to visit some off-the-path areas. And at the beginning of 2016, I made the decision to leave my job and make this trip happen. I targeted places I hadn't yet been able to visit, mainly Vietnam, but I didn't set a real itinerary. I had some vague routes that made geographic sense, but honestly had no end date set. Along the way I hoped to see cool sights, get off the b have fun, learn more about the world and global income inequality, visit friends, and also take "travel breaks" to learn the professional skills to transition to becoming a data scientist. I hadn't intended on this being a soul searching odyssey, but that happened regardless.

The trip weaved in and out of different phases. I departed Hong Kong for Hanoi on January 15, a week after my last day at work. I backpacked through Vietnam, Cambodia, Thailand and Laos, while I was more of a digital nomad in Bangkok, Malaysia and Singapore. The portion in Xinjiang felt like a separate trip altogether, after which I embarked upon familiar lands for a friends seeing tour. I returned to Hong Kong on March 28 but continued living out of my luggage for another two weeks there before arriving in Boston (via San Francisco) April 12, making for 35 stops in 96 days. These three months were some of the best days of my life and I tried to never forget how lucky I was to have this whole opportunity.

I get some flabbergasted responses when I recount the whole expedition, as if the whole idea was nuts. I get some nonchalant nods as well - while this may have been my most epic trip, there are plenty of ultramarathon voyagers who sneer upon my measly wanderings.  Some of these expert travelers were great sources of knowledge and inspiration to me. These include Tim O'Rourke, long time Hong Kong expat who tried to bike from Darjeeling to Ireland through Pakistan and Iran in the early 90s, Dave Learn, the long time Shenzhen expat who traveled around the world for over two years, John Johnson, whose Instagram photos have a cult following, and Sam Axelrod, who needs no descriptive appositive.

Vietnam

The instant I landed in Vietnam, I became a millionaire, with more Dong than I knew what to do. I immediately caught an overnight train north to Sapa, a mountain village I had only heard about a few weeks before.  I was in a nervous daze the entire ride, arriving in the chilly darkness into a remote train station an hour away from the town. It wasn't until a local bus took me a main-squarish place that the discomfort eased off and discovery took over.

And I discovered that I'd picked a hell of a start. A simple walk out of town led into gorgeous green valleys with rice terraces carving up steep slopes. The clear weather provided an incredible backdrop to what was probably the most beautiful place on my entire itinerary.  I took a chill hike down the valley to neighboring villages, and on the way back up to the town, I stopped by a cliffside coffeeshop / bar. Sipping egg coffee and beers, I watched as the fog rolled in and out of the valley outside my window, evolving from one sensational view to another. It was as pleasant a beginning as I could ask for.

Sapa was part of a rural mountainous area settled by at least 6 distinct ethnic groups. While it was difficult for foreigners to reach during a long weekend, Sapa was well frequented by backpackers. I quickly began to learn the demographics that made up the southeast Asia, or Banana Pancake Trail, backpacking crowd. There were few professionals based in Asia like me, and far more students in a gap year or about to start work, mostly from Western Europe and Australia. Likely due to greater student loans and a less prevalent traveling culture, Americans were few and far between.

On my second day, I summoned the nerve to rent my first ever motorbike to visit some waterfalls an hour outside town. I immediately braked too hard and fell. I came out of that fall alright and quickly got a grip, and was soon exuberantly cruising along mountain roads. Then the road turned to gravel and I came to a patch mysteriously being hosed by a man. I braked before reaching the puddle and suddenly found my bike skidding and my hands hitting the gravel hard. Emergency thoughts rushed through my head. "Is this how it happens? Is this how people die in accidents?" Half a minute elapsed before I could feel sure that nothing was broken. The man with the hose helped me up and an old man raced down from the hill. He led me to his hut and placed my skinned palms into a bowl of water and watch the gravel sift out. My palms, the right one especially, had little remaining skin. I was wearing long pants, but they had torn apart and left my left knee pretty scraped. I had to get my bloody palms back on the handlebars and finish my ride to a waterfalls. Luckily when I returned to my guesthouse to patch up my wounds, a German couple there revealed themselves as nurses and helped dress my wounds. The damage on my right palm, while superficial,  hindered my ability to carry bags for another month.  The good start to my trip had turned bad quickly.

On my bus from Sapa to Hanoi, I had the luxury of choosing assistance from the Dutch nurse or the Australian medical student to redress my wounds. Hanoi was a hectic city, with its unordered motorcycle madness crazy even when compared to Chinese cities. In terms of crossing the street difficulty, Hanoi is to Beijing as Beijing is to New York City as New York city is to Random Little Town. Within that chaos however, I was able to find lots of chill time within the city's many interesting cafes. The coffee was so good, oh so good, and the food maybe even better.

I stayed in the city's Old Quarter, not far from the west lake with its giant tortoise. Unbeknownst to me, this tortoise died while I was in Hanoi, leaving only three of its species left (am I such bad luck?). The area breathed of the narrow alleyways and makeshift market places, organically winding streets free of the bird's-eye decrees of urban planners. There was plenty of griminess - Hanoi is still in a developing country, but it's a capital with an illustrious history. The Hoa Lo Prison, or the Hanoi Hilton, was despite its dark nature probably the most interesting place I visited in the city. Though the war is long over, the prison/museum is full of propaganda trying to convince viewers that the American prisoners loved it there. I had known enough about John McCain's imprisonment there during the Vietnam War to question these accounts. Though the museum walls now seemed harmless, they were just eerie enough for me to imagine the horrors of McCain's experience being dragged down the same corridors. It was more fun to imagine how Donald Trump might have fared had he not dodged the draft. 

The storied Halong Bay was next. I visited in January, way out of season, and the bright green water and clear blue skies that so many photos had hyped up were nowhere to be found. Both sky and water were generic shades of grey. I joined a two day one night cruise with an interesting cast of characters. People often ask me, "who is the craziest person you met on your trip?" I think it's difficult to uncover the depths of another's depravity until you really get to know them, which doesn't happen too much while backpacking. However on that cruise, there was an old white haired, white bearded American who probably last shaved during the Reagan administration. Upon boarding, he immediately inquired about weed, which endeared him to the younger backpackers. He soon got weird. He was in his 60's and had not been in the US in over 30 years because it was too sinful. He was a Bible Literalist, believing every single word to be divinely inspired, and actually withstood scrutiny of hypocrisy. Another American girl Brook talked about her last name Long and how cool it was that Long means Dragon in Vietnam, and that Halong itself means Descending Dragon. Bible Beard then spoke about how dragons were the flesh incarnate of the devil and how terrible it was for the Vietnamese to worship them. Talk about buzz kill. Luckily the tranquil seas and green islands of Halong Bay were fun enough overall to drown out Buzzkill Bible Beard and the grey skies.

Next up was Da Nang and Hue, and the memorable bus trip and aviation party which I've documented already. Hue was cool and palatial (Hue Forbidden City) and I could have spent more time there exploring, but instead I chose to escape the rain and drink. Da Nang might seem like a boring modern city, but I enjoyed the chance to see a functioning industrious side of Vietnam. From Da Nang it was a short ride to Hoi An, a charming old port city which had eschewed the modern commercial duties to Da Nang and emerged instead as a touristy lantern-lit ode to a historical era. I loved Hoi An and how the tight Chinese-Japanese-Vietnamese urban architecture intermeshed with the gorgeous river scene. Though the town was small, I could have wandered around those pedestrian alleyways all day. The trip was greatly supplemented by a long bike ride to the beach with a French girl I had just asked to take my picture, and another ride out from town to the Terracotta Park, a random museum with clay models of world wonders, which I had learned from Mya at the aviation party. The liberated joys of backpacking - meeting fellow travelers and finding hidden gems - reached new highs in Hoi An. 

This high was soon to crash down. Sometime on my next voyage, a 16 hour bus ride to the mountain coffee town Buon Ma Thuot, I lost my phone. I spent about 24 hours mostly feeling sad, but I fit in 5 delicious cups of coffee, observant walks through a tourist-free city economy, and a great goat meat dinner with a retired Canadian couple.

Skipping the resort city Dalat, I headed straight to Ho Chi Minh City to a new phone. I was lucky to be offered housing from Sam & Quentin Axelrod, though they were both out of town. Their US consular housing provided a pitstop of luxury, with AC, TV, gym, wifi and an immense jewelled tiger (that Sam loves and Quentin hates). I also was able to connect with some ultimate friends and a Georgetown classmate who based his startup there. I learned that Saigon, or HCMC, is a surprisingly great city for startups. For a city of its level of development and quality of life, the cost of living is bizarrely low (sidenote: its abundance of skybars are also an urban outlier). A steady local graduate corps of programmers are readily and affordably available, and several co-working spaces have sprung up to make HCMC a go-to spot for location independent workers.

I planned my days to involve at least 2 coffee outings, interspersed amongst tourist site visits. My 5 days in HCMC were chill, with sobering trips to the Cu Chi Tunnels, the War Museum, and Saigon's Chinatown. I went into the tunnels confused about how a rag tag underground (literally) bunch could beat the US army machine, but left with an idea of the terror any American soldier must have felt entering those narrow dark trap-filled death corridors. I went into the war museum prepared to deflect the Vietnamese propaganda, but left aghast and abashed. Even if the Agent Orange exhibit inside was incredibly exaggerated, the US atrocities during the war were unfathomable. I felt deep shame for my country and my ignorance of this event. The Chinatown experience was less sobering, but still war-related. I walked around District 5 and found my way into a housing estate where I heard Cantonese. In the courtyard, a pair of adjacent stalls sold dumplings and tea respectively. I sat down and awkwardly started a conversation with a 50 year old enjoying his lunch. His vernacular was odd, with an unfamiliar word to be found in every sentence. He used a formal term for a soldier's march in lieu of the verb for walking. He went on to describe how the whole area used to be in Chinese, and how 4 in 5 residents left during or after the war. I asked him why he stayed, and his calm demeanor belied the sadness of his answer. "Most of them died leaving. The Chinese people have forgotten us. Few Hong Kongers like you want to visit us. But it's ok, life is pretty good here."

The rest of my Saigon experience consisted of expensive drinks at skybars, to the extent where I nicknamed the city Skygon. My first country and main impetus for the trip surpassed my expectations. The pho, banh mi and coffee defied the laws of economics in their quality and price. The foods that hadn't been popularized worldwide, My Quang and Bun Bo Hue and Banh Xeo, rocked my world. I had tasted enough of the food and learned enough of the language that when I entered a Vietnamese restaurant in Bangkok weeks later, I felt surprisingly at home. There was never a dull moment outside either. Cars didn't own the roads and pedestrians didn't own the sidewalks. Everywhere the motorbike was king. The system seemed to be in a state of dynamic flux, never at any equilibrium but somehow never breaking down.

Tuesday, April 26, 2016

Searching for a Bar in Kashgar

Why are these Chinese people speaking Arabic? It was 2008, and passing by a restaurant in Beijing I glimpsed a TV show with what looked like Arabic subtitles and became very confused. This was in fact my first encounter with Uyghurs speaking their language Uyghur, which is written using Arabic letters. From afar, China had seemed like a very homogenous country. It wasn't until that summer in Beijing and the Olympics opening ceremony when China paraded out its 55 official ethnic minority groups that I learned about the diversity of this huge country.

Not Arabic

The next summer, ethnic tensions flared into deadly riots in Urumqi. I watched from afar as pictures of citizens wielding hammers and knives on each other circulated, and heavy Han Chinese military presence moved in like an occupying army. The historical and racial dynamics transpiring out both fascinated and terrified me. The Uyghurs claimed that the Chinese were actively Sinicizing the area with an air of racial supremacy. The Chinese countered that they were bringing technological advancements into the area that gave the Xinjiang greater economic development than neighbors in Kazakhstan, Kyrgyzstan or Tajikistan. Both arguments are well-founded.

It was impossible for me to enter Xinjiang with an open mind. My liberal American value system far outstripped any sort of Pan-Chinese ethnic unity. However I have been living in the East for a while, and my outrage at the PRC oppression of Muslim minorities was chastened by my nation-neutral awareness of western hypocrisy. Xinjiang is unequivocally a modern Chinese colony, with its people and resources abused by a far away ruling power. But so are the Americas also stolen land from indigenous people, with the lack of outrage resulting not from good governance, but because the indigenous injured have been so decimated and assimilated. This doesn't excuse modern Chinese policies - limiting religious expression, encouraging Han migration to diffuse Uyghur culture and maintaining economic policies to keep a Chinese upper class - but it does make me pause before pointing one finger out and three fingers back at me.

Political backdrop aside, sitting in Guangzhou airport clutching a ticket with DESTN: URUMQI highlighted, an apprehension reared up that I hadn't felt in ages. It was befuddling - after traveling alone for over two months, now I was getting boarding jitters. Gone were the young European backpackers out to have some adventures. In Southeast Asia, nearly every destination came with a bus route and a dozen recommendations, but now I was jetting off alone entirely on my own initiative, to a land that had seen many foreign travellers in ancient times but far less in modern times. On one hand, these butterflies in my stomach were oddly refreshing. They reminded me of how I felt before I spent my first significant time abroad eight years ago, back when I was easily amazed by simple wonders. Since then I've spent too much time with people who unconsciously display their worldliness by acting matter-of-factly with new places.

We flew across the vast Gobi desert, which historically has been responsible for so much of the geopolitical history of the region and the intermittent relationship between the Han Chinese people and the Uyghur people. The sheer difficulty of journeying across deserts and mountains resulted in only the stablest of Chinese Dynasties interested in relations with their western neighbors. The Han Dynasty kicked off trade along the Silk Road, the Tang Dynasty resumed and furthered it, and the Mongolian Empire (Yuan Dynasty) facilitated it. It was really the Qing Dynasty though that extended Chinese territorial domain to Xinjiang, forming the basis for China's current self-proclaimed geographic mandate. I am certainly not alone in believing that Xinjiang and Tibet are not traditional lands of the Chinese people, but the PRC works hard to spin history to match their political agenda.
*****
Bizarre

Urumqi is a majority Han Chinese city, and the arrival experience at the airport felt like previous arrivals in Chinese airports. It is not nearly as old as the city I would fly into the following day. At the taxi line being hounded by black cab (unlicensed cars) drivers, I found myself unintentionally engaging in racial profiling - I'm not sure what it says that I was thrilled that my first cab driver in Urumqi was Uyghur. He initiated conversation by asking me where I was from, in strongly-accented Mandarin that unexpectedly sounded a lot like an American exchange student. "你是什么国家人?" We conversed about what he knew of America (very little), his travels outside Xinjiang (Beijing and Shanghai), his experience with other foreigners (entirely Russians and Kazakhs) and commerce in the city (more and more prosperous). He willingly teaches me a bunch of basic Uyghur words, most of which I've already looked up on omniglot but have never heard pronounced. "Rakhmat" he says, with a deep and guttural kh sound that I struggle to replicate. "谢谢。Thank you." "Men. 我。Sen.你。" We pull up in the middle of a crowded, dirty, poorly lit intersection and my driver takes another look at the address written in Chinese. "是这个。" This is it. At first glance I only see a despondent office building which looks like it couldn't gain a single LEED credit, but upon reading the upper level signs I realize my hotel is hidden somewhere above the 15th floor.

*****
Urumqi is the major city closest to the pole of inaccessibility, the point on this planet's landmasses that is furthest from any ocean. Yes despite the heavily populated coastal regions, China's borders also contain some very inland areas. Its latitude is around that of Portland, Maine which presented quite a shock to my body having flown in from Singapore, right at the equator. I was packed for a couple months of Southeast Asia backpacking, but amazingly I was able to scrounge together enough layers to not freeze. My underarmor proves extremely clutch underneath four layers of fleeces and shirts as I explore central Urumqi, where clumps of dirty snow still gathered on the sidewalks in late March.

Wikitravel had been a great guide throughout my travels but the wisdom of the crowds appeared to dissipate in Xinjiang. The article for Urumqi is noticeably less informative and grammatical as the one for Luang Prabang. I only have a morning to explore though and I choose to seek Erdaoqiao Bazaar. I read Rob Gifford's China Road as pre-trip research. Gifford visited Urumqi twice and was shocked to discover the second time around that this bazaar had been transformed from an incredible traditional Islamic market to an awful generic Chinese faux cultural block. Still, Wikitravel reports that the "surrounding area is the heart of the traditional Uyghur community" so I feel like it's worth a couple hours rather than my next best alternative, a hike up Red Mountain. The Erdaoqiao Bazaar actually looks quite interesting, with decorative Islamic arches spanning the upper level and a huge screen broadcasting loud Uyghur language programming. If I hadn't known it was "fake," built because of top-level Chinese directives, I would have thought it was a cool modern take on a traditional market. The doors were still locked, leaving me to meander through the surrounding streets, shivering.
Steamy

And what cool meandering this was. Massive smoky metal ovens churned out discs of naan while everywhere people were at work skewering raw lamb. I passed by numerous mosques with crescent tipped points towering into the sky. At one point I turned the corner and faced a stack of giant carpets and spent a moment in genuine wonderment expecting one to curl up and hover. I searched for the Tartar Mosque, supposedly at the southern end of Jiefang Road where I currently was. I found a couple of mosques in the area but they were rather unremarkable and didn't seem to match. Asking bystanders was met with confused responses. With a bit of guesswork and luck I found a large ornate mosque to the south of the Jiefang Road.

I caught a taxi back to the hotel. Even before asking, I suspected that my driver was from somewhere in Dongbei, Northeast China. In her thick accent, she told me she had been in Urumqi for 30 years and quite liked it. She seemed like a kind good natured woman. I offhandedly asked her if she had many Uyghur friends. "MEI YOU" she replied unexpectedly aggressively. No Uyghur friends. I was caught completely offguard. "There are communication problems," she elaborated. "Really? I've been able to talk to Uyghurs here, and your Mandarin is much better than mine," I replied. "They just don't understand us," and she left it at that. This perceived lack of communication both baffled and troubled me, as every Uyghur I met in my brief time in Urumqi had no trouble speaking Mandarin. I took a different look at her. She was most likely not highly educated and not received much cultural enlightenment. Perhaps I was experiencing the equivalent of asking a racist white driver in West Virginia if he had any black friends. Perhaps this isn't a fair comparison. Either way, it reminded that a progressive China was so very far away.
*****

In Kashgar, I settled into my former-Russian-consulate-turned-hotel, then quickly set out on foot towards the old town. My phone was a jumble of applications slow to load because of the wifi and applications that won’t load because of the Great Firewall. The Firewall has been beefed up significantly in the past years, now fully swallowing Google Maps, so for the first time in this 21st century Asian odyssey, I ask for a map.


The roads surrounding my hotel were unremarkable, just low density Chinese streets, until I walked past a clearing and glimpsed the old city wall, and a stable of camels quietly placed in front. Unexpected. The city wall was crumbling and surrounded by modern developments - while tall, it was remarkably unremarkable. The Old Town had a few actual marked entrances leading off into very different, triangularly tiled meandering paths. The lanes were quiet, with a few kids playing and the odd motorcycle humming by. Knee deep into the old town, I realized I'd never been anywhere like this. That's the simplest way I could summarize my experience. We don't get exposed to a lot of Central Asian culture in the United States. We hear about the Russians to the northwest, the Chinese to the east, the Indians to the south and the Persians to the southwest - we even went to war in nearby Afghanistan. Ironically the people in the middle of so much cultural development are eventually drowned out by those from the fringes. This position at the junction of so many civilizations very much shapes the city, as well as the lens I used to view it.

The Silk Road was not a road, but more like a series of routes that facilitated transcontinental trade from around 100 BCE to AD 1450. It obviously covered a lot of ground, but if you were to associate any one city with it, it would probably be Kashgar.
It is as close to the geographic center of the trade domain as you could pick, with routes leaving the city to the northwest, southeast and northeast. Trade items passing through the city included silk, jade, gold, frankincense, myrrh and religion carried by people from China, Arabia, Persia, Armenia, India, Tibet and many other Turkic or Indo-European people from the region.

In Kashgar I grasped around for memories in other places that can help me understand this place. The mosques and stately minarets were like elsewhere in the Islamic world, the lawless motorcycle driving like in Southeast Asia, and the chaotic outdoor market where Bluetooth sets were sold next to naan bread stands reminded me of India. There were herbal tea shops, meat butchered and hung out in the open air, buns steaming outside in baskets, and alleyways that conjured up cousins in Lijiang or Xianggelila. And there were some obvious signs of modern China, the white metal road barriers, the double strip of yellow rubber tiles on the sidewalk, the ubiquitous propaganda.   But really nowhere I've visited really connected. The closest experience I could really compare with was actually a series of photographs I saw documenting the Russian Far East in the early 20th century (link). I wasn't expecting this obscure memory to resonate, but the silk babushka scarves, the thick wool hats, the timeless but plain stonework, the hand crafting and the aged Eurasian features all echo here. Kashgar did not feel like a Chinese city - and I hope it never does.
*****
I had to resist the urge staring at every face. Growing up in a society where we are taught to demarcate between white, black, Asian and Hispanic, people who defy categorization fascinated me. Central Asians are often described as a mix between Caucasians and Asians, and certainly I found many features that did look halfway between East and West. What surprised me was the diversity of the people. There were people that looked straight up Russian, and others who were darker than many Indians. I summoned up the courage to ask many of these people if they were Uyghur, and they all said yes. There were others who looked more Chinese, and some who looked rather Arab. Overall though, most people did not look half-white half-Chinese - their features were simply unique. Sometimes we forget that human appearances cannot be broken down into constituent parts.
*****

All roads in the Old Town lead to corners of a main square, with China's largest mosque the Id Kah Mosque situated at the head. Some modern trappings include a very touristy set of camel statues, a knockoff KFC, and neon strips highlighting the arches of a few major buildings. The square was not overly touristy though, due to the fact that there were almost no tourists. On my first day, I saw no westerners save for one German family, and less than two dozen odd Chinese acting like tourists. The stores selling kitschy souvenirs were untrafficked, while people actually engaged in real commerce next door, purchasing socks and hats. Kids ran around the square yelling and flying kites, reminding me of the book The Kite Runner. The book is set in Kabul, but the movie was actually filmed in Kashgar. For some reason, filming in Afghanistan has been difficult in the 21st century, and Old Town Kashgar 500 miles away is apparently as well-preserved a Central Asian Islamic city as exists. Walking around the stone and dirt streets, I felt like I had entered a time warp. So many factors in the Old Town combined to create a 19th century atmosphere - the lack of motorized transport, the market bartering, outdoor craftwork and an incredibly low proliferation of modern clothing. My just wearing jeans was enough to stand out as a 21st century time traveler (basically no one mistook me for being Uyghur).

I turned the corner on a quiet residential alley and saw a grey wooden ladder leading onto the flat roof of a house. I immediately thought of Aladdin running through being chased by palace guards. Back out into the larger streets, a bunch of middle-aged men chatted while one of them hammered on an iron pot on an anvil. I stopped and stared at him work. I didn't know that anyone anywhere still made pots by hand, especially in this country with more factories creating these sort of goods than any other. He couldn't possibly be doing this for tourism reasons, because there is no tourism.

This New York Times article detailed a trip to Kashgar in 1994. It's amazing how much of the account matches my experience in 2016. In a country where cities are changing exponentially, I'm stunned that I've found a place so frozen in time.
 *****
The pilgrim monk Xuanzang, the leader of the pack in Journey to the West, went through Kashgar on his return trip from India in 640. Marco Polo came by around 1273. Xuanzang used a Sanskrit name for the city, Srikrirati, which the Chinese than obliterated in transliteration to Shule. Marco Polo called it Cascar. Though they came so many years apart, Kashgar was a major oasis trade center, by far the most magnificent city around, throughout this time frame. When Xuanzang came by, the area was probably Indo-European speaking, but the region had become Uyghur speaking by the time Marco Polo stopped by. I wonder if there remain any single stone on which these two travelers may have stepped. Probably not. (I have walked across the Lugou Qiao, or the Marco Polo Bridge, where Marco and I probably have shared stepping stones) Kashgar still feels like an old town, but was this main square even here during the Silk Road heyday? Xuanzang and Marco were both very multilingual, and probably could have communicated to the inhabitants here. I wonder if I could have communicated to either one. Xuanzang's Tang dynasty Chinese is the common ancestor of modern Mandarin and Cantonese, but probably largely unintelligible. I also have a basic grasp of ancient Latin and modern Italian, which might average out into Polo's medieval Venetian? There probably would have been a lot of hand gesturing going around.
*****
On the topic of communication, Mandarin ability among the Uyghurs ranges greatly, especially in Kashgar. One salesman told me "Zooey pianyi!" It took me a minute to realize he was butchering zui pianyi, or "cheapest price." Incredible. Do the Uyghurs learn Mandarin from reading Pinyin with English pronunciation rules, just like first year American students?

An entire restaurant staff didn't understand Mai Dan. I've never been anywhere in China where Maidan wasn't understood. I then said "check please," and the waiter returned with a pot of tea.
The English writing is universally terrible, which is hard to excuse in this age of decent machine translation. The writing on the "Fregrant Comcubine Tomb" looks like a google translate printout, from several versions ago with typos thrown in. It ends with "the German journal Bright Mirror goes: love between this Uygur maid and the emperor is evidence for greatunity among different ethnic groups in China. This structure is ranked as a key cultural relic unit under the protection of Xinjiang Uygur people's government."

Walking down the old town streets, almost everything was closed. I found one restaurant that seemed slightly open, but a woman stands right in front of me before I enter. She seems stunned and inadvertently blocking me, like I was a health inspector. I asked, "Can I sit?" and everyone immediately became more polite and pointed me to a table opposite a little kid slurping noodles. "Do you have a menu?" I asked. The waiter pointed to a piece of paper stuck on the wall with 8 lines in Uyghur. I looked back to him haplessly and he informed me, "We have two foods. 拉面,炒面. Pulled noodles, stir-fried noodles."

I checked my WeChat photos and found one of the guys watching over my shoulder. He asked/exclaimed that the photos were of Kashgar. I told him I was a tourist from the US, and we started a basic conversation. When he asked me something more complicated, I couldn't understand. He shook his head and started speaking in Uyghur, and I thought he'd given up until I realized he's talking to the kid. The kid looked up from his noodles and asked me, "你在美国干什么?" I'm flabbergasted. His accent was flawless. I'd not talked to a single 7 year old kid since I started traveling because none of
them could speak English. I asked, "gong zuo? Occupation?" The guy nodded. I decided not to say I was an unemployed aspiring data scientist, and simply said gong cheng. I expected to have to explain this as “make buildings”, but amazingly the kid translated immediately. I'm not sure if he really understood me, I had no conception of engineering at the age of 7, but I didn't press the point. I continued conversing with the restaurant staff, with the kid serving as a very disinterested translator. They asked me all these questions about America, like what's the weather like, that only made sense if you thought of America as a single place. I told them that like China, the US is large and diverse. I showed them the pictures I had on my phone of US and Hong Kong, and could only imagine the reference points they used to perceive these far off lands. “Nice car!” the kid exclaimed in a picture of DC townhouses. I hadn’t even noticed a car at all, but sure enough a BMW was parked in the foreground.

I asked them if they'd ever had a Han Chinese customer in the restaurant before. The staff shook their head emotionlessly. I honestly wasn't expecting this response. This restaurant was on a street just blocks from the main square. The Old Town was very much Uyghur area, but I would have thought at least one Chinese tourist would have grabbed a lamb skewer and sat down inside at some point over the years. "Rakhmat," I said leaving. Of all the times I've learned bits and pieces of a foreign language, never had I elicited greater smiles.
*****
I was doing a lot of walking and not a lot of drinking. I'd never been more isolated from drinking establishments in my life. Even though the Uyghurs are very devout Muslims, Chinese law prevails in town and there is nothing forbidding alcohol. I could walk down the Old Town streets drinking out of open bottles if I didn't mind antagonizing everyone around. However it seemed that an understanding had been reached and even in the Chinese parts of town, there was not the same open-Tsingtao-bottles-on-the-sidewalk culture as you'd find elsewhere in China.

LonelyPlanet directed me to Karakorum Cafe, which was closed, and Wikitravel told me of John's Bar in the "ancient british consulate." I make my way to the hotel that had also taken over this site and asked for John's Bar. I was met by an utterly flummoxed concierge. The hotel was uncharacteristically high-end, but after consulting with three other staffers, no one could direct me to a bar. I asked them where the old British consulate is, learned that the original building was just around the corner, but that I didn't want to go there. Ignoring their advice, I made my way in darkness to an empty old building, looking certainly haunted. Undoubtedly those ghosts may have had some amazing stories, but they were unlikely to have any beer for me.

I walked into a fancier restaurant looking for a bar. The first person I spoke to recoiled in fear and referred me to another waiter, who then referred me to yet a third waiter. This waiter then pointed outside and said quzhu. Minutes of wrangled communication ensued before I realized he was saying chuzu and telling me to take a taxi to a bar.

*****
We learned a bit about the Great Game in school, the political match between the British and Russian Empires for control over Central Asia. This explains the former Russian and British Consulates here. I never knew that China played a role in this game as well, and ultimately the crucial role in Kashgar's fate. Kashgar has been ruled by a lot of different nations over its history, and one of the last non-Chinese ruler in the 1870s was this opportunistic Tajik named Yaqub Beg whom Wikipedia just calls an "adventurer." By now, sea routes had replaced the Silk Road and westerners would attract a lot of attention in Kashgar. Yaqub Beg was coy with the great powers, playing them off each other. Eventually the Russians backed away and he tried to appeal to the British, but before any alliances materialized, the Qing Dynasty armies swooped in and deposed him.
***
If you visit Kashgar, try to be there for a Sunday, when people from all over the region gather to an enormous livestock market outside the city. There are probably four nationalities present trading four species - cattle, sheep, goats and a few packs of camels. I planned to wake up earlier and grab a taxi to the market before 11, and alertly responded to my alarm at 9:30. China is weird though in its insistence on one time zone. Kashgar is the westernmost city in China, more than 2 time zones behind Beijing, and thus the place in the world most screwed by illogical time zoning. Official "Beijing Time" was still used, but people utilized a local time two hours back for basic affairs. The sky was unusually bright that morning, and upon checking the time in different world cities, I realized that my phone had overnight somehow switched from Beijing time to informal Kashgar time, and what I thought was 9:30 Beijing/7:30 Local was actually 11:30 Beijing/9:30 Local. Scrambling my many layers of clothing together, I hurried to the lobby and ran into Abdul, the founder of a local tour company and one of two fluent English/Uyghur speakers I found in the city. "Going to the livestock market? I'm about to go myself to take pictures for my website." I jumped in the car with him and an older driver named Irkhan.


It's hard to say whether the Livestock Market is crazier because of the people or the animals. On the massive flat dirt field off the side of the road, organized chaos stretched to the horizon, making it difficult for me to gauge numbers.  The coats of the cattle and sheep ran the greyscale gamut with some brown in the mix. The livestock were tied with gentle ropes to sticks running down the market, while trucks would drive down in between and offload new cargo. Cattle were forcefully pulled down from the pickup trucks, but that did not compare at all to the challenging and often brutal upload process. I saw a truck driver overly optimistic about how many cattle he could drive away, and after much convincing of a reluctant cow, managed to fold her legs and squeeze her in with 7 other cows. It was udder madness. The market was at once both pandemonium and systematic - though the absence of signs and price tags left me confused, the challenging logistics of gathering all these farmers and livestock from miles away were made to look easy.

Amidst the bleats, baas and moos, a dozen or so camels had a row in the back of the market. They were fairly neglected, allowing me an opportunity to take a decent camel selfie, and I wondered what their use was to modern farmers. Surely they were no longer used for long range transport - perhaps they had more touristic end goals? It appeared that people may have been bartering livestock for livestock, but I also saw stacks of red Chairman Mao's in the mix. How odd it seemed to me that the man from Hunan was watching over the sales of goats between Uyghurs and Kyrgyz people in this field in Central Asia? I asked Abdul if he owned any livestock, not sure if this was even an appropriate question. He shrugged and said, “yeah, my family in the north have about 40 sheep. And a few cows.”

*****
The Old Town can maybe be walked in 20 minutes, if you walk quickly, which is difficult because of all there is to see. A bustling multi-lane modern road cuts it in half, under which tunnels lined with stores facilitate pedestrian traffic. A ring road essentially surrounds this main part of town, and another one around the greater urban area. Going south from the Old Town you reach the main east-west artery of Renmin Road, which is full of both new stores and street fruit vendors, with lots of Uyghur-Han commercial exchange. A bit further south though and Uyghur signs disappear almost entirely, and the area quickly transforms into a generic Chinese city downtown. Minarets vanish from view, replaced by Communist-style housing blocks with characters like 天南尚居 jutting into the sky. The city hall is on the south side of Renmin Road, situated behind a giant square that looks an awful lot like Tiananmen Square, with the red Chinese flag waving over everything. On the opposite of Renmin Road is a colossal concrete statue of Chairman Mao resting atop a colossal concrete block, reaching a height of 24m. The symbolism of placing such a large statue of a Chinese figure here is very in-your-face and a technique the British employed in many of their colonies. For maybe the first time in my life, I felt poignant Yellow Guilt. I felt pain for the attitudes and policies of people of my ethnicity, regardless of my lack of connection with the directly culpable.

I felt like I was traveling with a cheat code. This Central Asian culture with its bizarre bazaars should be off limits to me. Yet through a geopolitical quirk, the people of Xinjiang could speak Chinese, and even had adopted some Chinese mannerisms. Accustomed though I was to foreigners speaking Mandarin, I was still continually mindblown by seeing a mass of people casually dropping “aiyas” and “bukeqi” around.
The Chinese part of town had familiar supermarkets, bakeries and a very appealing hot pot restaurant. Uyghur food was great, but there wasn’t much variety beyond the noodles and lamb. Not many vegetables grow out in the desert. The hot pot place tempted me, but then I thought to myself I would have some great Chinese food in my next stop, Beijing. And in the stop after that. And for the rest of my life. I ate local again that night.
*****
I made out the words “Orange Street Bar” on the 2nd floor above street level behind some construction. Finally! My  drunk slump was over. The bar was discreet, with no open windows or loud music seeping out. It was a Chinese-style sit down place with a karaoke stage. I ordered a Tsingdao and watched as a Han woman went onstage to perform. To my surprise, she opened with Sam Smith’s “Stay With Me.” When she finished and walked off, I approached her and told her, “Your English is great!” She instantly disproved me by asking, “pardon?” I translated my compliment, and she told me she loved singing in English but wasn’t quite comfortable conversing in it. She sat down and told me her story. She was from northern Xinjiang, but had moved here to teach music at a local elementary school. I asked her if she ever considered moving to the bigger cities out east, but she told me people of her 户口, registered residency, have a hard time finding jobs outside of Xinjiang. She told me all her students were Uyghur and that she could hold a basic conversation in Uyghur. “Most Chinese don’t want to. Relations aren’t very good,” she mentioned. From her tone I could tell she was an “ally”, doing her part to improve social issues. From the corner of my eye I saw a male manager gesture to her, and she abruptly said goodbye and left. I finished the beers by myself, reassured and glad I had this conversation.
*****
I hustled out for a run the next morning. Like every city I’ve been to in Asia, Kashgar did not accommodate for outdoor runners. I dodged sidewalk stalls and errant motorcycles, despite their dedicated lanes.  Electric motorbikes dominated the scene, which was great for emissions and noise pollution but bad when I couldn’t hear them sneak up on me. As I ran past a park populated by playing children, a Han cop waved his hand at me. I warily made my way over, and he asked me what I was doing. Elsewhere in Asia, I had tried to hide my Americanness, but here with underlying racial dynamics, I pulled out my American card very hard. In English, I told him that I was a tourist and running. The cop asked in Chinese if I had ID. I told him I just had my hotel keycard and showed it to him. To my surprise, the cop inspected it carefully. A Uyghur cop joined in the fray and asked if I was a student. “No…I’m old..can I go now?” The Han cop gave me back my hotel key and I ran off. It seems this shakedown was more out of curiosity than anything else, but it never feels good to be pulled over by a cop for no reason.
****
Back at my compound, I found a sign for “John’s Information Service & Café.” It pointed to a very cluttered storage room. Apparently the café only opened during the summer – it didn’t make business sense to rely on the offseason patronage of the odd Chinese American alcoholic backpacker. I shrugged and set off for an exit in the back of the compound. Suddenly I glanced back and saw a pillared building….that looked suspiciously like a drinking establishment. What else was hidden in this former Russian compound? Dead bodies, AK47s and remnants of the Sino-Soviet split perhaps.
I returned to the suspected bar that night and found a club jumping so hot I couldn’t believed I only discovered it on my last night. All those blocks walked for a bar seemed pretty ill-conceived on hindsight, but such is life without GoogleMaps. Everyone inside was Uyghur. Aha! Perhaps the populace wasn’t as orthodox Muslim as I’d thought. A live band played traditional Uyghur music and the dance floor was very active. I nervously tiptoed to a table and scrolled through a menu of whiskey bottles, settling on two bottles of Stella Artois. The scene was so outlandish and dazzling that I never got properly grounded in my surroundings. The interior decoration included lamps and panels with intricate mosaic panels. Smoke and colored lights filtered the dance floor, while tables came standard with a hookah. All in all, the place was a pretty sweet venue.

I studied the dance floor closer though and saw that everyone looked at least a generation older than me, wearing what I can only describe as “granddad clothes.” Couples were dancing in pairs – a few women were dancing together. Something about the way they danced was odd though. After every song, they would break and file back to their seats, and the band would resume five or so minutes later. I looked around at the tables, studying the orange drink in the glasses, and suddenly I realized that quite possibly no one was drunk. The drinks may have all been tea or energy drinks. When the dancing resumed, I felt convinced that no one on that floor could possibly be inebriated. I felt ashamed for doubting the piety of these Kashgari Muslims. I briefly considered venturing onto the dance floor purely for the sake of this blog, then realized that there was nothing I’d less like to do, and hurried out of that place.